🎓 When Is the Right Time to Sell a Stock?

Knowing when to sell (and when not) is what separates good investors from great ones.

Oct 29, 2025

Every investor loves to talk about buying — discovering bargains, spotting the next multibagger, or investing early in a trend that’s starting to grow. But there’s far less talk about the other side — when to sell a stock.

Selling might seem easy, but it’s often the hardest part of investing. Do you take some profits after a big run? Sell when the stock keeps dropping? Or stay invested because you still believe in the company’s future?

Selling isn’t just about numbers, it’s about choices. It brings doubt, emotion, and the constant thought that you might have made the wrong decision. That’s why so many investors struggle with it.

In this article, you’ll learn why selling is one of the hardest parts of investing, when it’s the right time to sell, and when it’s better to hold. Let’s start with the psychology behind it — selling isn’t just about numbers, it’s also about emotions.

🧠 Why Selling Is So Hard

Buying a stock often feels exciting — it’s a sign of optimism and opportunity. But selling is different. It’s about making choices when things feel uncertain, and that’s something almost every investor struggles with.

When you buy, everything seems clear: you believe in the company, the numbers look good, and the story makes sense. But when it’s time to sell, doubt starts to build. Should you take profits after a strong run? Wait a little longer and risk losing those gains? Or hold on because you still believe the company has more room to grow?

Selling isn’t just hard when things go wrong — it’s also difficult when things go right. Letting go of a winning stock can feel just as uncomfortable as selling one that didn’t work out.

A big reason for that is psychology:

Loss aversion: we feel the pain of a loss much stronger than the joy of a gain.
Fear of missing out: we hate the thought of selling too soon and watching the stock climb higher.
Ego: it’s hard to accept that your original idea has played out — or that you might have been wrong.

These emotions make selling tricky in both situations. They can make us hold on to weak stocks for too long, or sell great ones too early.

The best investors know this. They stay calm, follow their plan, and don’t let emotions drive their decisions.

As Morgan Housel once said:

“Controlling your emotions is the most important investment skill you’ll ever have.”

If you can learn to stay calm when everyone else is emotional, you’ll already be ahead of most investors.

View our Portfolios

🎯 When It Does Make Sense to Sell

Selling doesn’t always mean you’ve made a mistake. Sometimes, it’s a smart thing to do. There’s no perfect timing, but there are moments when selling can make sense.

1️⃣ When the fundamentals change 📉
Every stock you buy should have an investment case — a reason you believe it can grow and create value over time. You invest because the company is growing fast, has strong margins, or is led by great management. But when that story changes — growth slows, profits drop, or leadership loses focus — it’s time to take another look.

If the fundamentals no longer make sense, holding on just because you own it usually doesn’t work out well. The best investors sell when the facts change, not their feelings.

2️⃣ When the valuation gets too high 💰
Even great companies can become risky when their valuation reaches extreme levels.
If a stock price runs way ahead of the company’s actual performance, it can be smart to take some profits or trim your position.

You don’t need to sell everything — just taking a little off the table can help you manage risk and stay balanced.

3️⃣ When there are better opportunities 🔄
Sometimes, selling isn’t about what’s wrong with a company, it’s about finding a better opportunity for your money. When you find a stronger business with more growth, higher margins, and better management, it can make sense to move your money there.

Good investing isn’t just about finding winners — it’s about knowing where your money has the most potential to grow.

4️⃣ When a position becomes too large 📊
When a stock performs well, it can slowly turn into too big a part of your portfolio.
Even a great company can add risk when the valuation is already high and the position takes up a large share of your portfolio.

Selling some shares isn’t weakness — it’s about staying disciplined and protecting what you’ve built.

🧘‍♂️ When You Shouldn’t Sell

After talking about when selling can make sense, it’s just as important to know when it doesn’t. Most of the time, the best move isn’t to sell — it’s to stay patient.

If you own strong, long-term businesses with a clear investment story, you don’t want to sell just because the stock moves up or down. Real wealth comes from giving great companies the time to grow, reinvest, and compound over many years.

1️⃣ When your thesis is still intact 💡
If the reasons you bought a company are still there, there’s no reason to sell. Short-term price swings don’t change long-term quality. If the business is still doing well, stay confident in your decision.

2️⃣ When a stock looks expensive, but the business keeps growing 💰
It often feels smart to sell when a stock looks pricey. But great companies can stay expensive for a long time — and they usually grow into those valuations over time.
Selling too soon can mean missing years of compounding and value creation.

3️⃣ When the price drops, but the business hasn’t changed 📉
Stock prices move up and down all the time, often driven by emotion, not facts.
If a company’s performance is still strong, a lower price isn’t a reason to sell — it’s often a reason to keep holding. The best investors focus on the business, not the noise.

4️⃣ Give compounding time to work ⏳
One of the biggest mistakes investors make is selling too early and breaking the power of compounding. Wealth builds slowly — and only if you give it time to do so.

In the words of Charlie Munger:

“The first rule of compounding is to never interrupt it unnecessarily.”

If the fundamentals are strong and your investment story still makes sense, patience is your greatest advantage. Sometimes, the best move you can make as an investor is no move at all.

🧩 Bringing It All Together

Knowing when to sell (and when not) is what separates good investors from great ones. Selling isn’t just about timing or numbers — it’s about patience, discipline, and trusting your process.

There are moments when selling makes sense: when the facts change, when a stock becomes too risky, or when better opportunities appear. But more often, the best move is simply to hold on — to let great businesses grow and compounding do its work.

The best investors don’t try to outsmart the market. They focus on owning quality companies, staying calm when emotions rise, and letting time create the results.

Stay patient. Stay focused. And let time work for you ✨

🔥 Upgrade now to paid and get 30% off!
Unlock full access to all deep dives, our portfolios, our monthly best buys — plus 350+ premium articles ✨

Upgrade for $329/year — that’s only $0.90 a day, and save $691 🔥
Cancel anytime ✅

Yes, I Want Full Access For $0.90/Day 🔥

Thank you for reading! 🙏
We put a lot of love into creating this post for you. If you enjoyed it, feel free to click the ❤️ button so more people can discover it on Substack or hit the ↪️ share button to share it with friends, family and fellow investors!

Don’t hesitate to share your thoughts in the comments — we’d love to hear from you 💬